AgResearch culling plans draw criticism

Aggrieved scientists aren’t alone in questioning the latest bout of proposed layoffs at AgResearch and the Government’s science policies.

A New Zealand Herald editorial notes that AgResearch is about to cull about 83 positions in research areas where, it says, “customer demand and the potential to create impact for New Zealand is decreasing”.

Customer demand is not something scientists used to have to worry about, but after the economy was exposed to world markets Crown research institutes were obliged to earn their income from industries. Since then, scientists and other research staff have suffered the insecurity and trauma that happens in all organisations in changing markets, and it never gets easier.

The redundancies at AgResearch are partly offset by plans to employ 18 scientists and nine technicians in new roles where demand is growing but the net reduction in 56 positions will be painful for those no longer required.

The editorial acknowledges  the slide in dairy prices since early last year may have reduced the industry’s research funds

…but neither AgResearch nor Federated Farmers have said that is the reason for the cuts. AgResearch has not said where its customer demand has declined, nor where it sees rising demand for that matter. Federated Farmers has blamed “inadequate funding” and “a lack of strategic planning” in agricultural research.

Its president, Dr William Rolleston, recalls that a Government taskforce in 2010 recommended core funding for Crown research institutes, along with more autonomy for them. “While this has happened,” he said, “the development of the National Science Challenges has tied up a significant proportion of core funding and made governance responsibility unclear.” It sounds like bureaucracy still prevails.

Dr Rolleston wants an increase in their core funding, which has not been adjusted for inflation since 2011, but he also believes AgResearch could be more effective in attracting funds from the Government and the private sector. New Zealand’s agricultural science is shrinking, he says. “Scientists are disillusioned and our youth [are] discouraged from science careers.”

If this is true, the Herald argues (“and scientists in a position to speak publicly say it is”) the country’s leading farmer organisation should help do something about it.

The sector contributes half the funding of some research programmes that are vital to further developing its products, improving its biosecurity and environmental performance and responding to the challenges and opportunities of climate change.Public funds inevitably come with bureaucratic procedures and programmes that can change on the whim of governments. These needlessly unsettle professional staff and undermine morale. Scientists need their farming sector funders to be alongside them, resisting capricious reorganisation and keeping them working towards discoveries that will keep New Zealand ahead of the game.

Anthony Robins, writing on The Standard blog, draws attention to a consequence particularly dear to his own heart:

Research cuts send negative signal to aspiring scientists

Just over half of AgResearch staff have been employed at the crown research institute for less than two years, a “staggering” figure says the New Zealand Association of Scientists (NZAS).

NZAS president Dr Nicola Gaston said by making the cuts the Government was telling young New Zealanders that careers in science were not for them. “This is a deeply concerning level of staff turnover for any organisation, let alone a science agency engaged in long-term research programmes which require continuity and stable working conditions,” Gaston said. …

Robins tells National everyone opposes cutting agricultural research. He further says it blows away even the pretense that the Government cares about climate change and demands: “What the hell are you doing?”

 

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: